Shelter Island Pet Friendly Vacation Rentals
About Shelter Island Vacation Rentals
There are more than 136 places to stay in Shelter Island and many that are available that welcome pets. These options include dog-friendly hotels, resorts, rentals as well as short-term private accommodations (i.e. RVs, Condos, Cabins, Chalets, etc.). The places can provide you with a great option on your next holiday. Compare many pet-friendly places to stay in Shelter Island.
Are you seeking a last-minute pets-allowed hotel deal, or are you wanting to find the best deals available for hotels, resorts, cottages, condos, private villas, chalets, or a large vacation homes? With PetFriendly Shelter Island, you can quickly compare different options to find the hottest deals with a single click. Looking for pet travel at a resort with an infinity pool, hot tub, is pet-friendly, or features a large master suite bedrooms or has a fireplace? You can find hotels, resorts, or other popular Airbnb-style properties in or near Shelter Island. Places to stay near Shelter Island are 846.26 ft² on average, with prices averaging US $1,089 a night.
PetFriendly makes it easy to find and compare hotels, resorts, and holiday rentals in Shelter Island with prices often listed at a 30-40% off the rack rate. Just enter your destination and secure your pet-friendly place to stay today.
Top Dog Hotels, Pet-Friendly Vacation Rentals, and Places to Stay in Shelter Island
| Type | Count |
|---|---|
| Vacation Homes | 109 |
| Holiday Apartments | 3 |
| Cottages | 3 |
Use these Quick Filters to Find a Vacation Rental in Shelter Island
★ Pro Tip: PetFriendly™ has the best results when it comes to finding places to stay that accept pets anywhere around the world. Travelers can find and compare over 10 million listings from all over the world. Use the intelligent Filter feature to compare homes, hotels, vacation rentals, bed and breakfasts, private Airbnb-style rentals, eco-friendly properties, inns, resorts, and more. Enjoy Pet Travel without Hassle in Shelter Island.
Weather in Shelter Island, NY
View the weather forecast for Shelter Island before booking your hotel or rental.
Stay Near Shelter Island, NY
PetFriendly finds and compares Pet-Friendly hotels, rentals, and resort listings near many of Shelter Island's attractions.
Other Places to Stay in Shelter Island, NY
Frequently Asked Questions About Shelter Island?
What are the top vacation rentals in Shelter Island?
Find the best options in or near Shelter Island for pet-friendly travel. If you are planning a trip or vacation in Shelter Island, consider a week or two at exciting pets-allowed hotels, resorts, or other suggested properties best known as Top Vacation Rentals and Places to Stay in Shelter Island:
- Work and Play Special! Extended Stay Discount
- Relaxing Private Retreat Near Preserve. Pets Welcome!
- Lovely home by the sea with dock and heated Gunite pool!
- Huge Island Getaway Pool Hot Tub Walk To Beach
- Waterfront Property on Shelter Island
- Shelter Island Retreat, 5 bdrms near everything!
- Chic Coastal Modern Ranch House with Private Pool, Steps from the Water .
- Ideal for 2 families, private, pool, close to beaches and marina Sleeps 12
- Serene 4-bedroom Craftsman cottage with Pool & Studio on Shelter Island
- Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach
Which vacation homes in Shelter Island are best for families?
Are you looking for a family-friendly and pet-friendly hotel, resort, or vacation home in Shelter Island? Check these highly-rated pet accommodations and places to stay with excellent reviews for families or groups staying in Shelter Island:
- Rustic & spacious 4 bdrm renovated farmhouse in lovely Shelter Island, LI
- Moonlit Manor l A Midcentury Shelter Island Vacation Rental Escape
- Stylish, Country 4 BR Retreat August Preferable
How many PetFriendly vacation rentals are available in Shelter Island?
PetFriendly™ updates its properties regularly to bring you a great selection of places to stay with their pet policies clearly spelled out. At present, the total number of active properties listed by PetFriendly in 2026 is over 136 in the Shelter Island area, and still growing every day. When we combine listings from multiple websites and travel providers, PetFriendly can provide you with a huge selection of the best places to stay that welcome pets in Shelter Island.
Nearby Neighborhood (5)
| Neighborhood | Property Count |
|---|---|
| The Heights Pet Friendly Hotels and Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island, New York | 518 |
| Menantic Creek Pet Friendly Hotels and Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island, New York | 295 |
| Coecles Harbor Pet Friendly Hotels and Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island, New York | 323 |
| Montclair Colony Pet Friendly Hotels and Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island, New York | 281 |
| Shorewood Pet Friendly Hotels and Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island, New York | 267 |
